The MRB process is the controlled route a nonconforming part or material takes when it cannot simply be reworked or scrapped under a standard procedure. A Material Review Board (MRB) brings Quality and Engineering together to decide what happens to the item, documents the reasoning, and tracks the case until it closes. In regulated manufacturing, the quality of that decision rests on two things: a specific technical rationale and a record that can be traced back to the exact part, lot and drawing characteristic. We build QA-Report so that inspection results, rejections and traceability data sit in one place, which is where an MRB case starts.
TL;DR
- MRB stands for Material Review Board: a cross-functional group, usually Quality Engineering plus the Engineering responsible for the design, that dispositions nonconforming material.
- Not every nonconformance needs the board. Items that can be returned to compliance by a documented standard method, a standard repair, or an obvious scrap-and-replace can be screened out.
- Typical dispositions are scrap, rework, repair, return to vendor, downgrade and use as is. Repair and use as is need a rationale specific to the defect and the end use.
- Customer approval is often mandatory. Prime contractors such as Boeing and Northrop Grumman define what a supplier's MRB may and may not decide.
- The record matters as much as the decision: NASA lists 16 recommended record elements, from unique item identifiers to the personnel who made the call.
Table of Contents
- What MRB means in manufacturing
- When a nonconformance goes to the MRB
- The MRB process step by step
- Who sits on the board
- Disposition options and when approval is required
- What records the MRB process should produce
- Common mistakes in MRB programs
- Where inspection software fits
- Promo: start with the data your board needs
- Perspective
- FAQ
- Sources
What MRB means in manufacturing
In manufacturing and aerospace quality, MRB means Material Review Board. (In other fields the same letters can mean something else, such as a Maintenance Review Board in aviation maintenance planning, but this article covers the quality meaning.) The board exists because a nonconformance is not always a simple pass or fail. A bore that is 0.02 mm oversize on a non-critical feature, a surface finish defect on a fitting that is machined again later, a casting with a porosity indication: each one asks an engineering question, not only an inspection question.
The board answers that question once, formally, so the shop does not rely on a verbal "it's fine" from whoever is nearby. The output is a documented disposition, the rationale behind it, and the names of the people responsible.
It helps to separate three terms:
- Nonconformance: a characteristic that does not meet the drawing, specification or purchase order requirement.
- NCR (nonconformance report): the record that opens the case and carries it through review.
- Disposition: the decision on what to do with the item.
When a nonconformance goes to the MRB
NASA's quality standard for its programs states that nonconformances presenting a significant safety, technical or programmatic risk to mission success are referred to a review board, which may be a Materials Review Board, a Risk Management Board or a Failure Review Board. The board investigates causes, assigns a disposition and tracks progress until closure. Commercial aerospace and defense primes apply the same logic through their supplier requirements.
The same NASA standard also says that some cases can bypass the board. Screening is acceptable when the item can be returned to compliance using a standard documented approach, repaired with a standard process, or when scrapping and replacing is readily established as acceptable for programmatic and technical risk. This keeps the board's time for cases that need engineering judgment.
A practical screening rule for a shop:
- If the fix is already written into a controlled procedure (for example, a documented rework operation), process it under that procedure and record it.
- If the item will be scrapped and replaced with no schedule, safety or customer impact, record the scrap and its cause.
- If the item must be accepted as is, or repaired by a method that is not standard, send it to the MRB.
- If the characteristic is one the customer has reserved for itself, send it to the customer's review authority.
Cases the customer reserves
Supplier flow-down documents spell out the limits. Northrop Grumman's QOS-0043 defines major nonconformances that a supplier's MRB cannot disposition. They must go to Northrop Grumman: interface nonconformances affecting the next-higher-level assembly, fatigue-critical details, aerodynamic smoothness nonconformances, and critical safety items under DFARS 209.270. Minor nonconformances may be processed by the supplier after approval.
Boeing's requirement IR 0451 adds a timing rule: the disposition of a noncompliant condition must be reported to Boeing immediately upon discovery, and submissions are made directly by the supplier, not by a Boeing representative, to protect data integrity.
The lesson is to read the purchase order and quality flow-downs before the first NCR is written. Whether your own board may decide is a contract question, not a preference.
The MRB process step by step
The steps below follow the common structure in aerospace, defense and medical device supply chains. Your customer's documents set the exact form.

1. Detect and contain
The nonconformance is found at incoming inspection, in process, at final inspection or from a customer return. The first action is containment: tag and segregate the item, and identify every other part that could share the condition, such as the same lot, setup, tool or material heat.
Where it goes wrong: containment limited to the single failed part. If the cause is a worn tool or a bad bar lot, siblings are still moving through the shop.
This is where inspection data pays off. When dimensional results are linked to the ballooned drawing characteristic and to the batch or serial number, you can see which other parts carry the same characteristic and the same lot. QA-Report flags out-of-tolerance results automatically against the measured dimension and supports batch and serial tracking, so the scope question has a data answer. Our guide to batch traceability covers how to set that up.
2. Open the NCR with a complete description
A board cannot decide on a vague report. The NCR should state the part number and revision, the drawing characteristic and its tolerance, the measured value, the quantity affected, where in the process it was detected, and who found it. The characteristic reference should match the balloon number on the inspection drawing so the engineer sees exactly what you saw.
Where it goes wrong: "dimension out of tolerance" with no balloon number, no measurement, and no revision. The reviewer then spends the first hour reconstructing facts.
3. Screen: MRB or standard disposition
Apply the screening rule above. Document the screening decision itself. An auditor will ask why this case did not go to the board, and "it was minor" is not a rationale.
4. Investigate and evaluate
The MRB engineer evaluates the defect against the engineering drawing, specifications, and, depending on the product, stress reports or repair manuals. A Héroux-Devtek MRB engineer job posting describes this work as identifying and analyzing the integrity of rejected components and confirming structural adequacy through design constraints and safety factors.
The investigation also looks for cause. NASA's standard says review boards seek root cause so that corrective actions are effective. Methods such as 5-Why, 8D and fishbone diagrams are common, and our overview of root cause analysis methods shows when each fits.
5. Assign the disposition
The board chooses one of the available dispositions (see the next section) and writes the rationale. If the customer must approve, the package goes out before any further work is done on the item.
6. Execute and verify
The disposition is carried out: rework or repair under a controlled work instruction, return to the vendor, scrap with witnessed destruction where required, or release as is. Reworked or repaired parts are reinspected, and the new results are recorded against the same characteristic. A part that is repaired and then never remeasured is a closed NCR with an open risk.
7. Close and feed back
The case closes when the disposition is verified and corrective action is assigned or confirmed. Trend the closed cases by supplier, process, characteristic and cause. Repeat nonconformances on the same feature point to a drawing, process or supplier problem that no single disposition will fix.
QA-Report's MES layer includes rejection and recovery tracking, and our rejection and recovery workflow walks through five audit-ready steps for the shop-floor side of this loop.
Who sits on the board
The board is cross-functional by design. Northrop Grumman's QOS-0043 states that a supplier's MRB consists of Quality Engineering and the Engineering responsible for product design. Each member requires approval by Quality Assurance and/or Engineering management, backed by documented resumes or MRB training as objective evidence. For its Independent MRB, the standard authorizes a maximum of three members from each of the Engineering and Quality disciplines.
Boeing's supplier requirements place responsibility for delegated MR authority with its highest level of organizational leadership for Quality Assurance and Engineering, including administration of the MR process and a training plan that describes content and duration.
In practice that gives you three roles to cover:
| Role | What it brings | What it signs off |
|---|---|---|
| Quality Engineering | Inspection data, process history, requirements | Containment, verification, corrective action |
| Design or Stress Engineering | Knowledge of function, loads and margins | Technical rationale for repair or use as is |
| Customer or authority representative | Contract and end-item authority | Dispositions reserved to the customer |
The MRB engineer role itself is often the person who runs the process: a Northrop Grumman Principal Engineer Quality posting describes leading the nonconforming material MRB process, coordinating investigations, documentation and dispositions, and performing root cause analysis, with AS9100-based audit support.
Disposition options and when approval is required
The usual dispositions are:
- Scrap: the item is rejected and removed from the flow, with replacement or remake as needed.
- Rework: the item is brought into full conformance with the drawing using an approved process.
- Repair: the item is made usable but does not fully meet the original requirement, so it needs engineering approval.
- Return to vendor: nonconforming purchased material goes back to the supplier.
- Downgrade: the item is accepted for a lesser application.
- Use as is: the item is accepted with the deviation, supported by rationale.
NASA's standard lists scrap, rework, repair, return, downgrade and use as is among the dispositions a review board may assign. The split between what a supplier can decide alone and what needs the customer varies by contract. Northrop Grumman's supplier reporting guide says that for covered purchase orders, suppliers may rework to specifications, return material to their vendor, or scrap and remake it. Suppliers without approved independent MRB authority must submit repair and use-as-is dispositions to the customer's MRB, and those dispositions are final and cannot be modified by the supplier.
Writing a rationale that holds up
QOS-0043 requires that use-as-is and repair dispositions be supported by rationale specific to the nonconformance and the end item usage, and that the MRB document include a determination of whether a document change is appropriate. A disposition without that reasoning is incomplete.
Compare two rationales for the same 0.05 mm oversize on a mounting hole:
- Weak: "Acceptable, engineering reviewed."
- Strong: "Hole is non-structural, located in a cover bracket with no fastener load path. Measured 0.05 mm over the upper limit on a nominal 6.00 mm; the mating fastener retains full thread engagement. No effect on form, fit or function. Drawing tolerance review recommended."
The second version states the feature, the measurement, the function, the effect and the document-change determination. It stands up to an auditor and to a customer.
What records the MRB process should produce
Traceability is the chain that links a decision to a physical part. A break anywhere, such as a missing serial number or an NCR that cites a superseded revision, leaves the board's decision without an anchor.
NASA's standard recommends 16 record elements for nonconformance records:
- Procurement or contract traceability
- Initiator
- Initiation and closure dates
- Document identification
- Unique item identifiers
- Quantity
- Occurrence count
- Detection point in the manufacturing process
- Nonconformance description
- Affected specification or drawing
- Proximate causes
- Root causes, when determined
- Supporting evidence
- Disposition
- Rationale
- Personnel responsible for the decision
NASA frames these records as part of acceptance data packages that let a program evaluate mission risks, product and material traceability and the final hardware configuration. That explains the granularity: years later, someone must be able to rebuild what happened to a specific unit.
Most items on the list are data you already hold in an inspection report: the part, revision, characteristic, measured value, lot and operator. Linking the NCR to the First Article Inspection or dimensional report, rather than retyping values, removes a common source of transcription errors. If your NCRs often cite FAI characteristics, the AS9102 FAI checklist shows what the underlying report should contain.
For teams studying how formal investigations and compliance records are documented in other equipment-heavy industries, these health and safety reports collect incident evidence and regulatory findings in one place.
Common mistakes in MRB programs
- Dispositioning before containing. The decision is made on one part while suspect lots keep moving.
- Skipping the customer check. A supplier MRB approves a repair that the contract reserves for the customer.
- Reporting late. Boeing's IR 0451 asks for immediate reporting upon discovery, and waiting for the next board meeting does not meet that.
- Using unqualified members. Where the customer requires approved members with documented evidence of training, an unapproved signature invalidates the disposition.
- Closing without corrective action. The same nonconformance returns next quarter.
- Keeping records in disconnected files. The NCR, the measurement data and the drawing revision live in three places and disagree.
Where inspection software fits
An MRB meeting is only as good as the evidence on the table. The faster and cleaner the inspection data, the shorter the review. QA-Report links ballooned drawing dimensions to measured results, flags out-of-tolerance deviations automatically, imports CMM data, and keeps drawings and documents in a document vault. Its MES layer manages parts, batches and operations with rejection and recovery tracking. For a quality engineer preparing an NCR package, that means the measured value, the balloon number and the batch are already connected.
Promo: start with the data your board needs
If your NCRs begin with re-keyed measurements and hunting for the right drawing revision, start at the inspection step. QA-Report offers a Free plan at $0 per month, Basic at $49.99 per month and PRO at $149.99 per month, with On-Premise and Enterprise Solutions for larger organizations or data-sensitive environments. See the plans and pricing to pick the tier for your team, or look at how CMM inspection software turns machine output into reports.

For shops that also run production through the same system, the MES software for machine shops page describes route cards, batch tracking and planning.
Perspective
A Material Review Board is a decision process, and a decision is only as sound as the facts in front of it. In our view, most delays in MRB come from evidence that is scattered: a measurement in one spreadsheet, a drawing revision in an email, a lot number on a paper traveler.
That is why we built QA-Report around a single chain. The ballooned drawing links to the measured result. The result links to the part, the batch and the operation. A deviation is flagged the moment it is recorded. When the board meets, the characteristic, the value and the lot are already connected, so the conversation can start with engineering rather than reconstruction.
We also think the record deserves the same care as the decision. A rationale tied to a balloon number, a revision and a serial number is one an auditor can follow without asking you to explain it. For regulated manufacturers in aerospace, automotive and medical devices, that is what turns a nonconformance from a finding into a documented, controlled event.
Michael Chen
FAQ
What does MRB stand for?
In manufacturing and quality, MRB stands for Material Review Board. It is the cross-functional group that evaluates nonconforming material and assigns a disposition. In aviation maintenance planning, the same letters can stand for Maintenance Review Board, which is a different body.
What does an MRB engineer do?
An MRB engineer evaluates rejected parts against drawings, specifications and engineering data, then recommends or approves a disposition with documented rationale. As the Northrop Grumman posting describes, the role includes coordinating investigations and documentation and running root cause analysis.
Does every nonconformance need an MRB review?
No. NASA's standard allows screening out cases that can be returned to compliance by a standard documented approach, fixed with a standard repair, or scrapped and replaced with acceptable risk. Cases outside those routes, and any characteristic your customer reserves, need board review or customer approval.
Can a supplier approve use as is on its own?
Only where the customer has granted that authority. Under Northrop Grumman's supplier guide, suppliers without approved independent MRB authority must submit repair and use-as-is dispositions to the customer's MRB. Check your purchase order and quality flow-downs first.
What should an MRB record include?
At minimum: the item identifiers, drawing and revision, the characteristic and measured value, quantity, detection point, causes, evidence, disposition, rationale and the people who decided. NASA's recommended list has 16 elements.
Sources
- NASA NPR 8735.2C, Chapter 6
- NASA NPR 8735.2C, Appendix E
- Boeing IR 0451
- Northrop Grumman QOS-0043 Rev G
- Northrop Grumman Supplier Nonconformance Reporting Guide
- Boeing D950-11135-1 Rev B supplier requirements
- Northrop Grumman Principal Engineer Quality posting
- Material Review (MRB) Engineer posting, Strongsville
- Health and safety reports
